A student can explain a concept immediately after it has been taught and still find it difficult to recognise that concept in a different situation. This is not unusual. Learning a definition, following a worked example, and using knowledge independently are connected, but they are not the same achievement. The ability to carry understanding into a new context is often described as transfer of learning.
Transfer matters because the world does not present knowledge in the same order as a textbook chapter. A learner may need to use mathematical reasoning while comparing prices, apply scientific ideas while interpreting a local environmental issue, or use historical thinking when examining a public claim. If knowledge remains attached only to the original exercise, its usefulness is limited.
Transfer is not simply repetition
Repeating the same type of question can strengthen familiarity with a procedure. But a new context asks the learner to recognise which knowledge is relevant and decide how to use it. A student who has practised calculating area from a diagram may need support to recognise the same idea when planning a garden or interpreting a floor plan. The mathematical principle has not changed; the surface features have.
The National Research Council’s work on learning and transfer explains that prior knowledge can support new learning, but it can also lead learners in the wrong direction when an earlier pattern is applied without considering the new situation. This is a useful reminder for teachers: students do not arrive as empty pages, and prior understanding is not always automatically helpful. Teaching needs to make connections visible and help learners examine when an idea applies.
How an idea travels
Teach the connection, not just the answer
One practical approach is to place two examples side by side and ask students what is similar and what is different. The examples should not look identical. A science teacher might compare heat transfer in a classroom demonstration with a familiar household situation. A social science teacher might ask learners to examine how a concept appears in a textbook case and in a local public issue. The aim is to help students identify the underlying principle rather than copy the surface pattern.
Another approach is to ask students to explain why a method works. “Which operation did you use?” is a useful question, but “Why was that operation appropriate here?” asks for a deeper connection. In language learning, students can compare how a sentence changes across different audiences or purposes. In arts education, they can discuss how a design principle works in a poster, a classroom display, and a public sign.
Assess transfer with unfamiliar but reachable tasks
If every assessment repeats the exact format used during teaching, it may tell us more about practice than flexible understanding. A transfer task should be new enough to require thought but not so unfamiliar that it becomes a test of unrelated background knowledge. Students need enough information to enter the problem, and teachers need to know what kind of support is appropriate.
When a student struggles, do not conclude immediately that the earlier learning has disappeared. Ask what part of the new context is confusing. Is the learner unable to recall the concept, unable to recognise its relevance, or unsure how to adapt it? These are different difficulties and call for different teaching responses.
Questions for lesson planning
- Where might students encounter this idea outside the exercise in which it was taught?
- What prior knowledge might help, and what earlier assumption might mislead?
- Can I compare two examples that look different but share a principle?
- Will students explain why a method fits the situation?
- Does the assessment require them to make a decision rather than copy a familiar pattern?
Transfer does not happen simply because a teacher says, “Use this in real life.” It needs deliberate teaching, varied examples, opportunities to explain connections, and tasks that invite learners to make choices. Knowledge becomes more useful when students can recognise it, adapt it, and carry it into situations they have not rehearsed word for word.
Illustration: Original AI-generated artwork created for IncludiaTrust for this article. View the image source.
Further reading
- National Research Council. (2000). How People Learn: Learning and Transfer. National Academies Press.
- National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2018). How People Learn II: Learners, Contexts, and Cultures.
