When students are asked to assess their own work, the instruction is sometimes reduced to a simple question: “How many marks would you give yourself?” That may be appropriate in a carefully designed activity, but it is not the heart of self-assessment. Learners do not become reflective simply because they are asked to grade themselves. They need to understand what quality looks like, notice evidence in their own work, and make a decision about what to do next.
Self-assessment is therefore a learning practice, not a transfer of the teacher’s marking responsibility to the child. The teacher still has an important role in clarifying expectations, modelling judgement, identifying misconceptions, and checking whether a learner’s interpretation is reasonable. The aim is to help students become more capable of monitoring their own thinking over time.
Begin with an intention students can understand
A learner cannot judge progress against an intention that remains vague. “Write a good paragraph” is difficult to assess. “Write a paragraph that makes one clear point, supports it with an example, and explains how the example connects to the point” gives students something visible to look for. The criteria should be limited enough to guide attention rather than turn the task into a checklist of every possible feature.
Teachers can model the process with an anonymous or teacher-created example. Think aloud while reading it: “The main idea is clear. I can see an example, but the connection is not yet explained. I would add one sentence here.” This shows that assessment is a form of reasoning. It is not a mysterious judgement that only an adult can make.
A learner’s three-part review
What did I actually do?
Which part meets the intention?
What will I change next?
Use evidence, not confidence
Some students will say their work is excellent because they are confident; others will describe a strong piece of work as poor because they are unsure of themselves. Self-assessment should not depend on either confidence or modesty. Ask learners to point to the sentence, calculation, diagram, or decision that supports their judgement. “I think this is clear because…” is more useful than “I think I did well.”
It can help to use two versions of the same task: an early attempt and a revised attempt. Students can identify one change they made and explain why it matters. They might also compare their work with a model, while remembering that a model is an example of quality rather than a template that everyone must copy word for word. This distinction protects creativity and different ways of expressing understanding.
Keep the teacher in the process
Self-assessment can be inaccurate at first. That is not a reason to abandon it. It is a reason to teach it. A teacher may notice that a student has misunderstood a criterion, is judging handwriting instead of meaning, or is overlooking an important step. A short conference can help recalibrate the judgement. Peer discussion can also make criteria clearer, provided the classroom is safe enough for students to disagree respectfully.
Research by Nicol and Macfarlane-Dick connects formative assessment with students’ capacity to regulate their own learning. Their work is useful because it treats learners as active participants who generate and use feedback, not simply as recipients of teacher comments. The principle can be adapted to school classrooms without assuming that younger learners should manage their learning alone.
Questions students can learn to ask
- What was I trying to show?
- Where can I see that in my work?
- Which part is not yet clear?
- What is one change that would make the work stronger?
- What help or resource would make that change possible?
The value of self-assessment is not that students become their own examiners. It is that they gradually become better readers of their own work. They learn to notice quality, explain decisions, recognise uncertainty, and take responsibility for a next step. The aim is not to make children mark themselves; it is to help them understand how learning can be improved.
Illustration: Original AI-generated artwork created for IncludiaTrust for this article. View the image source.
Further reading
- Nicol, D. J., & Macfarlane-Dick, D. (2006). Formative assessment and self-regulated learning: A model and seven principles of good feedback practice. Studies in Higher Education, 31(2), 199–218.
